Posts

Showing posts with the label Quarreling with God

Quarreling with God

Quarreling with God Numbers 20:13 Excerpt But they had quarreled only with Moses ( v .  3 ). Elsewhere Israel’s quarrel with Moses implies that their real object is God ( 14:2–4 ,  11 ,  27 , esp . v .  9 ).25 Indeed, the next quarrel ( 21:5 ) makes this explicit. Moreover, Deuteronomy bears the tradition that the people are responsible for Moses’ punishment ( Deut. 1:37 ;  3:26 ;  4:21 ) as does  Psalms 106:32–33 , “They provoked wrath at the waters of Meribah and Moses suffered on their account, because they rebelled against Him [or “embittered his spirit”] and he spoke rashly.” 26  Psalms 95:7–11  bears yet another variant tradition: Israel’s forty years in the wilderness was due to its sin at Massah-Meribah ( see   Exod. 17:7  and  Excursus 50 ) and not to the scout episode ( 14:26–35 ;  Deut. 1:34–35 ). Hence, Moses and Aaron must die with them in the wilderness.  More Milgrom, Jacob.  Numbers ....

Quarreling with God

Quarreling with God Numbers 20:13 Israelites quarreled with the LORD But they had quarreled only with Moses ( v. 3 ). Elsewhere Israel’s quarrel with Moses implies that their real object is God ( 14:2–4 , 11 , 27 , esp. v. 9 ).25 Indeed, the next quarrel ( 21:5 ) makes this explicit. Moreover, Deuteronomy bears the tradition that the people are responsible for Moses’ punishment ( Deut. 1:37 ; 3:26; 4:21 ) as does Psalms 106:32–33 , “They provoked wrath at the waters of Meribah and Moses suffered on their account, because they rebelled against Him [or “embittered his s pirit”] and he spoke rashly.”  Psalms 95:7–11 bears yet another variant tradition: Israel’s forty years in the wilderness was due to its sin at Massah-Meribah ( see Exod. 17:7 and Excursus 50 ( Numbers 20:1-13 ) and not to the scout episode ( 14:26–35 ; Deut. 1:34–35 ). Hence, Moses and Aaron must die with them in the wilderness.27 Milgrom, Jacob. Numbers. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, ...

Quarreling with God

Quarreling with God Numbers 20:13 Israelites quarreled with the LORD But they had quarreled only with Moses (v. 3). Elsewhere Israel’s quarrel with Moses implies that their real object is God (14:2–4, 11, 27, esp. v. 9).25 Indeed, the next quarrel (21:5) makes this explicit. Moreover, Deuteronomy bears the tradition that the people are responsible for Moses’ punishment (Deut. 1:37; 3:26; 4:21) as does Psalms 106:32–33, “They provoked wrath at the waters of Meribah and Moses suffered on their account, because they rebelled against Him [or “embittered his spirit”] and he spoke rashly.”26 Psalms 95:7–11 bears yet another variant tradition: Israel’s forty years in the wilderness was due to its sin at Massah-Meribah (see Exod. 17:7 and Excursus 50) and not to the scout episode (14:26–35; Deut. 1:34–35). Hence, Moses and Aaron must die with them in the wilderness.27 Milgrom, Jacob. Numbers. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1990. Print. The JPS Torah Commentary.